AI image
Both options let you temporarily import goods (exhibits, equipment, a stand) without paying duty, provided they are re-exported. An ATA Carnet is a ready, internationally recognised document, convenient for multiple countries and frequent trips. Temporary admission is a customs procedure opened in the country of import, often simpler for a single country or one-off event.
What is the difference?
The difference is not whether you pay duty (in both cases temporary import is duty-free when goods are re-exported), but how you handle it formally. An ATA Carnet is a single document you carry with you, cleared at every border crossing. Temporary admission is opened and discharged on site, in the destination country. The carnet travels across many borders; temporary admission is usually tied to one country of import.
When to choose an ATA Carnet
An ATA Carnet works well when:
- the goods visit several countries on one route (for example a series of fairs or an equipment tour),
- trips are frequent and repeatable and you want one predictable document,
- you value the recognition of the same document at many borders without opening a fresh procedure in each country,
- you carry typical fair and event items: exhibits, samples, display equipment, stand components.
The carnet is cleared at every border, so its strength is repeatability and not having to agree a new procedure with a local office each time.
When to choose temporary admission
Temporary admission can be simpler when:
- the cargo goes to one country for one event and returns the same way,
- you do not plan to move the same equipment across further borders,
- the type of goods or the nature of the operation fits a procedure opened locally in the country of import.
In that scenario a single travel document (a carnet) offers no advantage, and the procedure only needs to be opened once and closed once in the destination country.
What to watch for
Whichever you choose, one rule is absolute: goods imported temporarily must return within the set period and in the same condition. Keep the item list complete and consistent, mind the re-export deadlines and the correct clearances at each border, because these decide whether the procedure is properly discharged. The choice depends on the number of countries, the frequency of trips and the type of goods, so settle it before the cargo sets off. The terms are explained in our glossary (ATA Carnet) and under temporary admission.
ATA Carnet vs temporary admission: a comparison
| Criterion | ATA Carnet | Temporary admission |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Ready, internationally recognised document | Customs procedure opened in the country of import |
| Number of countries | Convenient across many countries | Usually one country of import |
| Frequency | Good for frequent, repeatable trips | Good for a single event |
| Clearance | At every border crossing | Opened and discharged in the destination country |
| Re-export | Required | Required |
| Typical use | Route through several countries, a series of fairs, an equipment tour | One country, one event, return the same way |
The OTSL role
At OTSL we match the solution to the specific trip, not the other way round. Before the cargo moves, we establish the number of countries, the frequency and the type of goods, then run the transport and customs clearance so the procedure opens and closes with no surprises at the border. Planning a fair, an event or a temporary equipment export? Write to us through the contact form, and our customs clearance team will help on the customs side. More decision guides are in our knowledge base. See also: ATA carnet for trade fairs, when you need it and how it works and Insuring trade fair exhibits: the risks from hall to hall.
Step by step
- Defining the purpose and transport route. Determine how many countries you are transporting equipment to and whether it involves a single event or a fair circuit.
- Selecting the appropriate customs procedure. Choose between obtaining an ATA Carnet and opening a standard temporary admission procedure at the border.
- Preparing a detailed inventory list. Create a precise packing list including technical specifications, serial numbers, and item values.
- Presenting documentation at the border. Submit the full documentation set to customs authorities upon entry into the destination country for registration.
- Closing the procedure via re-exportation. Arrange return transport and ensure customs clearance is officially closed before the set deadline expires.
Definitions
- ATA Carnet (Admission Temporaire/Temporary Admission Carnet): An international customs document replacing standard declarations to allow duty-free temporary import and export of goods.
- Temporary admission (temporary import procedure): A customs procedure opened directly in the destination country, allowing goods to enter duty-free subject to re-exportation.
- Re-exportation (re-export): The mandatory step of removing temporarily imported goods from the destination customs territory within a specified timeframe.
- Exhibits and event equipment: Goods transported for trade fairs or demonstrations that are not intended for sale in the local market.
